Site icon PaySlipBanSA

Competition Commission Cheats on Policy

job advert pay secrecy is unlawful

Custodians of the same law they flout, a cheating Competition Commission had a flimsy draft recruitment policy available for our scrutiny in 2018. Let’s take a look at the first few sections.

Policy and Praxis

There is a lack of cohesion between what CompComSA states in policy and what they do in action. 

We caught them advertising vacancies without being upfront about pay and demanding cost-to-company information from applicants.

When confronted on social media, they promptly removed the offensive adverts, replacing them with ones stating a salary range. They refused to engage with PaySlipBanSA or investigate our complaints.

Pay secrecy and unfair information advantages are actual, yet they claim to aspire to:

The realisation of Vision 2030 at the Competition Commission of South Africa (CCSA) (the “Commission”) is premised, amongst other things, on putting employees and people management at the centre of the realisation of the goals of the institution and the creation of a high-performance culture in the institution.

The Competition Commission (“Commission”) has defined the imperative of becoming a High Performance Agency as one of its Strategic Goals. The Commission has identified the attraction and retention of Talent as key to the realisation of the High Performance Agency and fulfilment of its mandate. The Commission recognises the need to contribute to the redressing of the imbalances of the past by creating opportunities for the previously disadvantaged and implementation of the Employment Equity Plan to achieve a staff profile that is representative of the demographics of South Africa.

EQUITY FUTILITY

Evidence shows that pay secrecy discourages women, CompComSA’s notion of achieving equity is incorrect and their conduct fails to match.

Policy Purpose Claims

The Competition Commission is supposed to:

Illusion of Principles Hides Collusion

Below is Comp Con’s list of principles, note they make no mention of promoting a fair competition for talent in order to protect economic freedoms as enshrined in the Competition Act.

What’s wrong with @CompComSA?

  1. Some job adverts are transparent about pay, others not. Their actions and principles are thus inconsistent.
  2. Pay secrecy is not in keeping with the Constitution, the highest law of the land.
  3. Pay secrecy discourages women.
  4. Pay secrecy allows unequal treatment and prejudice to enter the labour market value chain.
  5. Contradicting the Competition Act, the Competition Commission destroys fair competition for talent by endorsing the practice of spying on other firms compensation structures when competing for talent.
  6. The Competition Commission makes it compulsory for some of their applicants to disclose cost to company information, yet price-fixing pay is illegal.
  7. The use of information asymmetry during recruitment places the Competition Commission at an unfair advantage during wage negations.
Exit mobile version